Tracy V.
Hot subs and onion rings😋
Our Story
About Mateo's Pizza
At Mateo's Pizza, we make pizza the way we believe it should be made. The dough gets time to develop, the sauce is prepared with care, and we don't cut corners because we're invested in this neighborhood. Families trust us with their meals and celebrations because they know we're not answering to anyone but them. As Bob T. shared, "My wife and I consider ourselves pizza fanatics. Since our first date back in 1976 we have tried hundreds of pizza spots across the northeast. Mateo's is worthy of being added to our regular rotation list !" We know our regulars by name, and new customers become regulars because they feel that commitment from day one. We're grateful to be part of the Cairo community and serve our neighbors.
There's always more at Mateo's Pizza
What people are saying
What our customers are saying about Mateo's Pizza